Whether you’re lighting your very first cigar or you’ve been enjoying fine tobacco for decades, the J.C. Newman Cigar Company offers a cigar that perfectly matches your taste, experience level, and budget. Founded in 1895, J.C. Newman is America’s oldest family-owned premium cigar manufacturer, blending more than 130 years of tradition with exceptional craftsmanship. Today, the company produces everything from luxury, premium cigars to outstanding value and bundle cigars, making it one of the most diverse portfolios in the premium cigar industry.
If you’re wondering which J.C. Newman cigar is right for you, here’s a look at five standout brands that showcase the company’s remarkable range.
Diamond Crown Classic: The Ultimate Luxury Cigar
If you’re looking for one of the finest premium cigars available today, Diamond Crown Classic Cigars are difficult to beat.
Originally introduced more than a century ago as one of J.C. Newman’s luxury brands, Diamond Crown was reintroduced in 1995 to celebrate the company’s 100th anniversary. Handmade by the legendary Arturo Fuente family in the Dominican Republic, these cigars are crafted using meticulously aged tobaccos and undergo an extensive aging process before ever reaching cigar smokers. The Diamond Crown Classic features a smooth complexity that makes it approachable for newer smokers while offering enough nuance to satisfy seasoned cigar aficionados.
Strength: Mild to Medium
Flavor Profile:
- Cream
- Cedar
- Toasted nuts
- Baking spices
- Natural sweetness
Typical Price: $15–$30+ per cigar
Diamond Crown is a J.C. Newman Cigar Company brand that encompasses many cigars including Black Diamond Cigars, Julius Caesar Cigars, and Diamond Crown Maximus Cigars, each with their own flavor profiles, strengths, and sizes. But whichever cigar you select, the Diamond Crown brand is ideal for cigar enthusiasts celebrating life’s milestones or anyone seeking an exceptionally refined smoking experience.
Best For: Luxury cigar lovers, special occasions, weddings, and gifting.
Brick House Double Connecticut: Smooth, Creamy, and Surprisingly Flavorful at an Everyday Price
For cigar smokers who enjoy a mellow, creamy smoke without sacrificing complexity, the Brick House Double Connecticut is an exceptional choice.
Part of J.C. Newman’s award-winning Brick House family, the Double Connecticut blend offers a modern twist on the classic Connecticut-style cigar. Hand rolled in Nicaragua, it features a silky Connecticut Shade wrapper over a Connecticut Broadleaf binder with premium Nicaraguan filler tobaccos, hence the name “double Connecticut.” This unique tobacco combination delivers remarkable smoothness with more depth than many traditional Connecticut cigars.
Strength: Mild to Medium
Flavor Profile:
- Cream
- Toasted almonds
- Cedar
- Buttered toast
- White pepper
- Light baking spices
Typical Price: $8–$11 per cigar
The Brick House Double Connecticut is an excellent choice for newer cigar smokers, morning cigars with coffee, or experienced enthusiasts looking for a smooth, balanced smoke. While it’s approachable in strength, the Nicaraguan fillers provide enough body and complexity to keep seasoned smokers engaged from the first light.
Its flawless construction, easy draw, and consistent burn have made it a favorite among Connecticut cigar fans who want more flavor than a typical mild cigar without stepping into medium-full territory, and with an every day price range.
Best For: Connecticut cigar lovers, beginners, morning smokes, pairing with coffee, and anyone seeking a creamy, mild-to-medium premium cigar with outstanding value.
Cuesta-Rey: A Timeless Classic
Few cigar names carry as much history as Cuesta-Rey.
Dating back to the late 1800s, Cuesta-Rey has remained one of J.C. Newman’s most respected heritage brands. Today, the line is handcrafted in the Dominican Republic using premium Dominican tobaccos and continues its reputation for elegance and consistency. The brand offers multiple blends, allowing smokers to choose everything from mellow Connecticut wrappers to richer Sun Grown options.
Strength: Mild to Medium (varies by blend)
Flavor Profile:
- Cedar
- Cream
- Almond
- Toast
- Light pepper
Typical Price: $8–$15 per cigar
Cuesta-Rey is an excellent choice for smokers who appreciate traditional cigar craftsmanship and balanced flavor without overwhelming strength.
Best For: Morning cigars, new premium cigar smokers, and lovers of classic Dominican cigars.
Perla del Mar Maduro: Rich Flavor Without the Premium Price
For smokers who enjoy dark wrappers and naturally sweet tobacco, Perla del Mar Maduro delivers tremendous value.
The Perla del Mar Maduro combines premium Nicaraguan binder and filler tobaccos with a rich Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro wrapper to create a complex yet balanced smoking experience. Rolled and pressed in the J.C. Newman PENSA factory in Nicaragua, the box pressed design of these cigars give them a unique edge that fit comfortably against the lips.
Strength: Medium
Flavor Profile:
- Dark chocolate
- Espresso
- Molasses
- Sweet earth
- Black pepper
Typical Price: $6–$9 per cigar
Perla del Mar Maduro provides the richness many smokers associate with premium Maduro cigars while remaining remarkably affordable.
Best For: Maduro lovers, medium-bodied cigar fans, and smokers looking for exceptional value.
Quorum: The Best Value Handmade Cigar
Not every great cigar needs to come with a premium price tag.
Quorum Cigars have become the world’s best-selling imported handmade bundle cigar by delivering honest quality, dependable construction, and outstanding value. Handmade in Nicaragua using quality tobaccos, Quorum is available in Classic, Shade, and Maduro varieties, giving smokers plenty of choices regardless of preference.
Strength: Medium
Flavor Profile:
- Earth
- Cedar
- Toasted tobacco
- Light spice
Typical Price: Approximately $3–$5 per cigar (purchased in bundles)
Quorum is an excellent option for everyday and budget-conscious smokers who want premium handmade construction without paying premium prices.
Best For: Daily smoking, beginners, golf rounds, fishing trips, and value cigar enthusiasts.
Which J.C. Newman Cigar Is Right for You?
One of the reasons cigar enthusiasts continue to trust J.C. Newman after more than a century is the incredible variety within its portfolio.
- For luxury and celebrations: Diamond Crown Cigars
- For bold everyday flavor: Brick House Cigars
- For classic Dominican elegance: Cuesta-Rey Cigars
- For rich Maduro character: Perla del Mar Maduro Cigars
- For unbeatable everyday value: Quorum Cigars
Whether your preference leans toward a smooth Connecticut Shade cigar, a bold Nicaraguan blend, or a rich Maduro wrapped smoke, J.C. Newman offers a handcrafted cigar to fit your palate and your budget.
Experience More Than 130 Years of Cigar Excellence
Choosing a cigar isn’t just about strength or wrapper color—it’s about finding the experience that matches the moment. J.C. Newman has spent more than 130 years perfecting that experience through family tradition, exceptional craftsmanship, loyal friendships, and a commitment to quality.
From the luxurious refinement of Diamond Crown to the incredible everyday value of Quorum, every cigar in the J.C. Newman portfolio reflects generations of expertise and a passion for premium tobacco. No matter where you are on your cigar journey, you’ll discover that J.C. Newman truly has a cigar for every palate.